BREAKING: Gayle Benson and New Orleans Saints urged to replace Derek Carr with veteran playoff QB from AFC in 2025…

Breaking News: Gayle Benson and New Orleans Saints Urged to Replace Derek Carr with Veteran Playoff QB from AFC in 2025

In a stunning turn of events, Gayle Benson, owner of the New Orleans Saints, and the team’s front office are being urged by multiple sources and analysts to make a bold move in 2025. The call is to replace Derek Carr, the current starting quarterback, with a veteran playoff-caliber QB from the AFC. The Saints’ disappointing offensive performance during the 2024 season has sparked growing concerns, leading to this push for a significant change at the most important position on the field.

The Current State of the New Orleans Saints

The Saints entered the 2024 season with high hopes for their offense, having signed Derek Carr in the offseason. Carr, a former Pro Bowler with the Las Vegas Raiders, was expected to be the stabilizing force for a team that had struggled at the quarterback position since the departure of Drew Brees. Despite a solid defense and skilled offensive weapons such as Chris Olave, Michael Thomas, and Alvin Kamara, the Saints’ offense has underperformed, and Carr’s play has been at the center of the criticism.

Through the first half of the 2024 season, Carr has shown flashes of the talent that made him a starting quarterback for years in Las Vegas, but inconsistency and inability to elevate the offense in key moments have plagued the team. The Saints have been stuck in mediocrity, with many blaming Carr’s lack of performance for their struggles to secure a playoff spot in a competitive NFC South division. As the 2024 season progresses, the pressure is mounting on head coach Dennis Allen and the front office to make significant changes to ensure the team’s future competitiveness.

A Call for Change

As the Saints face another year of underachievement, the conversation surrounding Derek Carr’s future in New Orleans has only intensified. Despite being a seasoned veteran, Carr has struggled with turnovers, inaccuracies, and a seeming inability to lead the team in crucial moments. With the Saints’ playoff hopes on the line in 2025, the idea of bringing in a veteran AFC quarterback has gained traction. Several analysts and former players believe that a more experienced and proven quarterback could help the Saints return to contention in the NFC, particularly with their strong defensive unit and weapons on offense.

One of the key arguments being made for replacing Carr is the lack of postseason success. While Carr has been a consistent starter in the NFL, his lack of deep playoff runs has caused many to question his ability to take a team to the next level. The Saints are in a win-now window, and a quarterback with more playoff experience and a proven track record in high-pressure situations is seen as necessary to elevate the team’s chances of returning to the Super Bowl.

The Veteran AFC Quarterback Candidates

While there is no definitive list of quarterbacks the Saints could target, there are several veteran AFC quarterbacks who have the pedigree to make an immediate impact in New Orleans. The Saints are expected to explore all options, including potential trade deals and free-agent acquisitions, with an eye on bringing in a quarterback who has a proven ability to perform in the postseason.

One name that has been floated by several NFL insiders is Ryan Tannehill of the Tennessee Titans. Tannehill has led the Titans to multiple playoff appearances and even came close to taking them to the Super Bowl during the 2019 season. His ability to manage a game, his leadership skills, and his experience in big moments could be exactly what the Saints need. While Tannehill has faced criticism in recent years for his inconsistency, his overall playoff experience makes him a strong candidate for the Saints to consider if they are seeking a proven veteran to step in immediately.

Another quarterback that has generated buzz is Jimmy Garoppolo of the Las Vegas Raiders. Garoppolo has earned a reputation as a playoff quarterback with his success in San Francisco, where he led the 49ers to a Super Bowl appearance in 2020 and multiple NFC Championship games. Though injuries have hindered his career, Garoppolo’s experience in the postseason, his ability to execute an efficient, balanced offense, and his leadership qualities make him a plausible option for New Orleans. Garoppolo’s skill set could complement the Saints’ existing offensive weapons, making him a strong fit for their scheme.

Additionally, there has been speculation around Mitch Trubisky of the Pittsburgh Steelers. Though Trubisky has faced criticism throughout his career, particularly after a mixed stint with the Chicago Bears, he has proven to be a capable backup and has demonstrated poise in playoff situations during his time with the Steelers. Trubisky’s ability to push the ball downfield, his playoff experience, and his potential for growth in a new system could be intriguing for the Saints, especially if they are looking for a quarterback with upside and leadership qualities.

The Urgency for the Saints

The call for the Saints to replace Derek Carr with a veteran quarterback is not one that is being made lightly. With a defense that has been consistently strong and a roster that features several Pro Bowl-caliber players, the Saints are in a win-now situation. While the team has the potential to make a deep playoff run, Carr’s struggles in big games and his inconsistency have raised serious questions about whether he is the right quarterback to lead the Saints back to the Super Bowl.

For Gayle Benson and the Saints’ front office, the decision on whether to move forward with Carr or seek a more experienced playoff quarterback is critical. The team has invested a great deal in building a competitive roster, and they now need a quarterback who can capitalize on that talent. With the 2025 season on the horizon, the Saints are looking to make a bold move to ensure their continued competitiveness in the NFC and take full advantage of their championship window.

Conclusion

As the New Orleans Saints prepare for what could be a pivotal offseason in 2025, the pressure is on to make a change at the quarterback position. While Derek Carr was brought in to stabilize the position, his underperformance in crucial games has led many to believe that the team needs a veteran playoff quarterback to lead them back to the promised land. The potential candidates from the AFC, including Ryan Tannehill, Jimmy Garoppolo, and Mitch Trubisky, offer a range of options for the Saints, each bringing unique strengths and playoff experience to the table.

For Gayle Benson and the Saints organization, the future of the franchise hinges on making the right choice at quarterback. If the Saints make a bold move in 2025 and secure a proven veteran under center, they could be positioned to make a deep playoff run and ultimately contend for another Super Bowl title. The clock is ticking, and the team’s next move could define the course of their future for years to come.